How Gender Inequality Is Reproduced on Social Media

IOE researchers Elizaveta Sivak and Ivan Smirnov have analyzed over 60 million public posts on VK, the most popular Russian social networking site, to discover that both men and women mention sons more often than daughters. They have also found that posts featuring sons receive 1.5 times more likes. The results have been published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.  

In recent years, social media have become an important source of data for researchers. In particular, it allows them to observe everyday social interactions and to get insights into the reproduction of gender inequality.

Elizaveta Sivak and Ivan Smirnov used public posts about children made by 635,665 users from Saint Petersburg on the most popular Russian social networking site VK. Common topics for such posts included celebrations of different achievements and important events (19%); expression of love, affection, and pride (26%); and reports on spending time with the children (27%).

The results demonstrate gender imbalance: there are 20% more posts about sons than about daughters on social media. Sons are more often mentioned by both men and women. This difference cannot be explained by the sex ratio at birth alone (106 boys to 100 girls in Russia), thus indicating gender preference in sharing information about children. Previous studies have shown that children’s books are dominated by male central characters; in textbooks, females are given fewer lines of text; and in movies, on average, twice as many male characters as female ones are in front of the camera. Gender imbalance in public posts may send yet another message that girls are less important and interesting than boys and deserve less attention.

The researchers also found that posts about sons receive, on average, 1.5 times more likes. The posts about daughters written by the mother, on average, receive 6.7 likes from women, and 1.1 likes from men. Their posts about sons get 10.7 likes from women and 1.8 likes from men. Father's posts about daughters receive 5.3 likes from women and 2.6 from men. Their posts about sons receive 6.7 likes from women and 3.7 from men.

It means that women like posts more often than men, that women prefer posts written by women and men prefer those written by men, and, most importantly, that both women and men more often like posts mentioning sons.

‘This imbalance could be an indication that girls are less significant than boys. The fact that posts about sons get more likes only enhances this effect,’ says Ivan Smirnov, the co-author of the paper and Head of the IOE Educational Data Science Lab.

’The gender preference in sharing information about children may seem quite harmless compared with other layers of gender disparity. However, given the widespread popularity of social media, even moderate bias might accumulate. Millions of users are exposed to a gender-biased news feed on a daily basis and, without even noticing, receive the reaffirmation that paying more attention to sons is normal.’